Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Listing photo for 456 Broadway, Monticello, NY
Previous View the Previous slide Next View the next slide

456 Broadway,

Monticello, NY

$8,500,000

13,225 Sqft
0.55 Acres

Premier Downtown Investment Portfolio | 7 Mixed-Use Buildings + 1 Parking Lot | Village of Monticello, NY. A rare opportunity to acquire a stabilized commercial real estate portfolio in the heart of the Village of Monticello's Central Business District. This offering consists of seven mixed-use buildings and one commercial parking lot, strategically positioned along Broadway, the Village's primary commercial corridor. With a combination of established income-producing properties and significant value-add opportunities, this portfolio is ideal for investors seeking immediate cash flow with long-term appreciation and redevelopment potential. The portfolio includes a diverse mix of retail storefronts, professional office space, restaurants, and a residential unit, creating a well-balanced investment with multiple income streams. Several properties feature long-term tenants, while vacant suites provide opportunities to increase occupancy, rental income, and overall portfolio value. Ownership has invested substantially in capital improvements throughout the portfolio, including: Updated electrical systems, High-efficiency HVAC and mini-split heating and cooling systems, New windows, Updated flooring and interior renovations Security system installation, Municipal water and sewer service throughout the portfolio. One of the portfolio's most compelling features is the opportunity to significantly increase revenue by completing more than 5,000 square feet of undeveloped space. Subject to Village approvals, this area may be converted into professional office suites, residential apartments, or other permitted uses, creating substantial additional rental income and enhancing the portfolio's long-term value. The properties are located within the B-2 Business District, which permits a broad range of commercial and mixed-use uses, including: Retail and wholesale businesses, Professional and medical offices, Service businesses, Restaurants and eating & drinking establishments, Funeral homes, Residential uses. Other compatible commercial uses as permitted by the Village. The portfolio also includes a dedicated commercial parking lot, providing a valuable amenity for tenants, customers, and future development opportunities. The parking lot can continue to generate income, support existing buildings, or serve future expansion plans. SBL'S included in this sale - 111-5-16, 111-5-3, 111-7-4, 111-7-3, 111-7-6, 111-5-17, 111-3-17, 111-5-18

Facts & Features
MLS® # 1021962
Price $8,500,000
Bathrooms 0.00
Square Footage 13,225
Acres 0.55
Type Commercial Sale
Sub-Type Mixed Use
Status Active
MLS hgmls
Community Information
Address 456 Broadway
City Monticello
County Sullivan
State NY
Zip Code 12701
Amenities
Utilities Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Water Connected
Parking Alley Access, On Street, Parking Lot, Private
Is Waterfront No
Has Pool No
Interior
Heating Forced Air
Cooling Central Air
Has Basement Yes
Basement Full
Fireplace No
Exterior
Construction Brick
School Information
District Monticello
Elementary George L Cooke School
Middle Robert J Kaiser Middle School
High Monticello High School
Additional Information
Date Listed July 30th, 2026
Days on Market 10
Zoning B2
Short Sale No
RE / Bank Owned No
Listing Details
Listing Courtesy of Curasi Realty, Inc.
Mortgage Calculator

This mortgage calculator can be used to figure out monthly payments of a home mortgage loan, based on the home's sale price, the term of the loan desired, buyer's down payment percentage, and the loan's interest rate.

Purchase & Financing Information

Yes, I would like more information from Coldwell Banker Village Green Realty. Please use and/or share my information with a Coldwell Banker Village Green representative to contact me about my real estate needs.

By clicking Inquire I agree a Coldwell Banker Village Green Realty representative may contact me by phone or text message including by automated means about real estate services, and that I can access real estate services without providing my phone number. I acknowledge that I have read and agree to the privacy policy 

Listing information last updated on August 9th, 2026 at 7:05pm EDT.